A Green Revolution, Part 2 – Insanity

Immediately after posting about Iran, I read an amazing op-ed in the New York Times that very explicitly calls for American, not Israeli, military action against Iran:

The final question is, who should launch the air strikes? Israel has shown an eagerness to do so if Iran does not stop enriching uranium, and some hawks in Washington favor letting Israel do the dirty work to avoid fueling anti-Americanism in the Islamic world.

But there are three compelling reasons that the United States itself should carry out the bombings. First, the Pentagon’s weapons are better than Israel’s at destroying buried facilities. Second, unlike Israel’s relatively small air force, the United States military can discourage Iranian retaliation by threatening to expand the bombing campaign. (Yes, Israel could implicitly threaten nuclear counter-retaliation, but Iran might not perceive that as credible.) Finally, because the American military has global reach, air strikes against Iran would be a strong warning to other would-be proliferators.

Marc Lynch has a brilliant response to the article, in which he makes two very helpful points:

1) That the op-ed appeared in the New York Times and not the Post or the WSJ is helping bring the ‘option’ of bombing Iran into the mainstream, whereas it had been relegated to the unthinkable in the last few years; and

2) This idea is completely nuts.

I would like to give Alan Kuperman (the op-ed author) props for realizing that an American attack would stir up anti-Americanism in the region.  It would, drastically.  I would also like to give Kuperman props (for lack of a better word) for completely and utterly ignoring this point.  Wow.  Stunning.

Update: Read more reactions to the op-ed at the Wonk Room and at Foreign Policy (Drezner)


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s