Will SCAF move to reform the security sector?

Right after posting a call for security sector reform in Egypt,  read a post on Foreign Policy by Ty McCormick highlighting just how closely the new state security structure resembles the one that terrorized Egyptians under Mubarak. McCormick’s piece underlines just how necessary it is for SCAF to push forward meaningful reforms in this sector in order to ensure that the earthquake that was the Egyptian revolution does not simply transform into an authoritarian transition period. In other words, real, fundamental change is required in Egypt to ensure basic freedoms – and this process can start with SCAF. Unfortunately, SCAF is far to worried with prosecuting Egyptian protesters than it is with putting former regime officials to justice or starting real reform. From McCormick:

The trial of former interior minister Habib el-Adly, the mukhabarat (intelligence) boss for 14 years under President Mubarak, was postponed for the third time on Sunday. His trial, now scheduled for August 3, will be a combined affair with Mubarak, who also stands accused of ordering the deaths of almost 900 protesters during Egypt’s 18-day revolution.

The intelligence chief was expected to stand trial for murder in May — after being sentenced to 12 years on corruption charges — but a Cairo judge pushed the start date back a month after angry protesters attempted to swarm the courtroom.  His trial was postponed a second time — without explanation — on June 24, igniting four days of protests that left more than 1,000 people injured when security forces clamped down using tear gas and rubber bullets.

Anger at El-Adly’s interior ministry boiled over during this year’s protests. Crowds of Molotov cocktail-toting protesters laid siege to the building in the early days of the revolution, defying ministry snipers who opened fire on them using laser sights.

During El-Adly’s tenure, the ministry detained and tortured with impunity, using its estimated 500,000-member police force to terrorize the public into submission. At the height of the protests in January, El-Adly is also thought to have withdrawn police officers from the street and turned prisoners loose in an effort to scare democracy activists back into their homes.

It comes as little surprise, therefore, that the postponement of his trial was met with a mixture of cynicism and outrage by many Egyptians. Wael Eskandar, a blogger and journalist for Ahram Online, told Foreign Policy in a phone interview that “most protesters don’t believe that [the Supreme Council of Armed Forces (SCAF)] is serious about trying Adly.” They are irked for the most part, he said, but “they are not expecting any real form of justice.”

There is increased concern, moreover, that a Mubarak-Adly trial won’t materialize in August, either. As Kristen Chick, the Cairo correspondent for the Christian Science Monitor, said in an email, people are “increasingly worried and jaded that the military does not intend to prosecute Mubarak.” Adding to their concern is the fact that Ramadan, the Islamic month of fasting, falls in August this year, making it highly unlikely that a trial will get underway. As the New York Timesrecently put it, during Ramadan “most Egyptians fast all day, feast much of the night, and little else gets done.”

But the sleepy month of Ramadan will be less of a problem than SCAF’s unwillingness to hold the old regime accountable, according to Eskandar. “The police who killed protesters are still in their places while they are waiting for trial,” he said.  Meanwhile, many families who lost loved ones during the revolution have been offered bribes to drop charges against ministry officials, according to Eskandar. “When they don’t accept bribes, they are threatened with [trumped-up] drug charges,” he said.

Similar reports of police bribery surfaced in June, when families of victims of police brutality claimed that they were offered blood money by informants affiliated with the Imbaba police department.

Not all justice dispensed by SCAF is justice delayed, however. For many of the protesters rounded up during the revolution, retribution has been swift. Human Rights Watch reports that at least 5,600 civilians have been sentenced by military tribunals since Mubarak was unseated on February 11. One such civilian was 26-year old Maikel Nabil Sanad who was sentenced to three years after he wrote on his blog that “the army and the people were never one hand,” a reference to one of the revolution’s widely used refrains. Sanad did not even have the luxury of legal counsel during his sentencing, since his lawyer had been fed misinformation about when it would occur.

Inconsistency between SCAF’s handling of the trials of former regime officials and those of protesters is wearing the people’s trust thin, and has translated into popular unrest on more than one occasion. “While people here right now may not agree on a lot of things, nearly everyone agrees that they’d like to see Mubarak hanged,” said Chick.

Photo from Flickr



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s