The Egyptian Military’s Broken Promises

Has the Egyptian army taken over the revolution?

Since the Egyptian military helped the people bring down Hosni Mubarak and created the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces (SCAF) to act as an interim government, there has been nearly no revolutionary changes, leading many to downgrade Jan25 from a revolution to a military coup. Despite the demands of the Egyptian people, SCAF has done little to alter Mubarak’s governing structure. Protests against SCAF have been dispersed, the security services remain largely intact and the interim government is looking awfully far from interim. Fortunately Al Ahram Online has provided a useful chart displaying what promises made by SCAF were met, which were broken and which were left unfulfilled.  For those counting, that is 10 broken promises, 6 unfulfilled promises and only 4 fulfilled promises (and one unknown.)

Promise Status Source
Rebuild the church in Atfeeh, Helwan before Easter Fulfilled Media Release
Rebuild the churches in Imbaba and compensating for damages Fulfilled Communiqué 48
Release of some civilians subjected to military trials Fulfilled Communiqués 29, 30,36, 40,55
Investigate Hosni Mubarak and his family Fulfilled Communiqué  35
Hold parliamentary elections in September Broken Media Releases
Leave power within 6 Months Broken Media Releases
To protect protests and protesters Broken Communiqués 1, 68 and others
Answer queries within 24 hours Broken Communiqué  2
Execute necessary reforms that meet the legitimate demands and aspirations of the Egyptian people Unfulfilled Communiqué  6
Take all necessary precautions to ensure military police does not deal violently with protesters Broken Communiqué  22
Release all arrested on 25 February Broken Communiqué  23
Presidential Elections will not be postponed to 2012 Unfulfilled Communiqué  28
Investigation into the torture of female protesters and taking corrective actions Broken Communiqué  29
Military trials only used for acts of thuggery Broken Communiqués  30, 68
Bring those involved in corruption and killers of protesters quickly to justice, return stolen wealth and equality of citizens before the law Broken Communiqué  31
Investigate Zamalek vs African match events Unfulfilled Communiqué  32
Egyptian media has the complete freedom to discuss any topic, military never interferes Broken Communiqué  42
Egyptians abroad to vote in next elections Unfulfilled Communiqué  49
Retry all youth subjected to military trials Unfulfilled Communiqué  50
Investigate the death of Ramy Fakhry Unfulfilled Communiqué  53
Take the side of revolutionary youth Unknown Media Releases; numerous Communiqués

Photo from 3Arabawy (H/T to Michael Collins Dunn)

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s